Battle OOC

[Liu Bei/Admin]

Post here for Battle OOC...

Alright, just two questions from me...

To Shiv

Erm... The mountain crumbling? How? The Stone Sentinel Maze on my behalf was pre-planned and created by Liu Yu pre-battle, all I did was give it a flashy entrance, it's pretty much the same as building it as I need two turns...

Secondly, only five turns to train troops, and get supplies let alone returning all the way to Jiangdong... Unless you're training them in another region, which is most likely enemy... And stealing the supplies...

[Yuan Rui (Hei An)]

k I didn't see that building that maze being prepared, just saying is not fair to the opponents, as I think they would know of something being build by the enemy soon, in this case for sure as the environment doesn't let you hide your plans to build something. What I mean here, is if you had noted you were building that maze there 2 turns ago, they could have tried to prevent it at an earlier stage. Now its almost finished without your enemy have any chance to stop it.


Also that large amount of troops from Liu Yu.. 250,000 added in 1 turn, and suddenly in the center of the battle map.. how did they get there so fast, if they were there all that time, it should have been noted earlier in a post too.

I can go on and criticize everyone there, but I think it's better to start this battle again, in which the battle mod Pm's every member who is participating their amount of troops and officers and give them the area they can use to set their troops basically up. So for example
I say The Han gets 50,000 troops and 4 officers and have them occupy areas 1-5 the way they like. Then the one controlling the Han (Huangfu Song here I guess) can say he places 10,000 troops in area1-4 each, leave 5 unoccupied and have 10,000 troops come as reinforcements within 2 turns in area 3. The map can stay the same, but the maze wont be there and the bridge wouldn't be destroyed yet.

So I would like to hear from others if they agree to restart the battle or not

[Cao Cao]

I'd like a restart too. It's been an unorganised mess since the start, with no form of moderator present. With no magic...

EDIT: Don't restart it, I wanna crush you now Joe and execute you all on the riverbank!

[Shivam (Xun Yu)]

HI GUYS.

Uhh.. I don't know how to answer the first question.

Second one: I'm not going to train them, I'm going to leave the less experienced ones in Jiang Dong and collect the more experienced men. I wouldn't bring everyone in Jiang Dong .hehe.

Supplies... It can't take THAT long to get supplies. After all, there are cities on the way to Jiang Dong that could possibly belong to the Pirates. And as you stated above, the pirates could also steal some supplies. The possibilities are endless if you think about it.

I personally don't mind a restart, to make this battle a bit fairer, but it's up to you guys.

[Liu Bei/Admin]

Yeah... A really disorganized mess...

I believe a restart would be appropriate, the troop count went out of hand, I only used magic to counter such large armies.

Anyway, I believe that the mods should dish out a preset troop count... And us participants should stick to it I mean 1.5m Troops for Shiv? Unreasonable considering that they are just pirates...

Now people should be warned... The stone sentinels are indeed on the map... I'll add up a thread in the rules tomorrow, involving fire attacks etc. A

And who wants to use an RTK map?

[Yuan Rui (Hei An)]

I dont, rotk maps arent my favorites, u fix maps then an expansion of the rules would be good, so this wont happen again (it was fun though to c u bringing more and more troops)

[Liu Bei/Admin]

Expansion on Battles is up, take a look guys, that should clear things up...

And I have decided that I shall mod the restarted battle myself, Jing Troops will not participate, unless Adam/Liu Feng wishes to take control of the battle as Liu Feng.

So guys, thread locked, new one started PM me secret plots, and Adam, PM me if you want to participate.

Kev, you can help me mod the battle... Everything will be considered...

Oh, and the Stone Sentinels are available for use, PM me